Table 5 FAIR vocabulary feature applied. Assessment results of Gene ontology, Experimental factor Ontology and ICD-11
FAIR vocabulary Feature | Vocabulary | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Gene Ontology | Experimental Factor Ontology | ICD-11 | |
FVF-1: Vocabulary and their terms are assigned globally unique and persistent identifiers. | Full Compliance | Full Compliance | Partial Compliance |
FVF-2: Vocabularies and their terms have rich metadata. | Full Compliance | No Compliance | Full Compliance |
FVF-3: Vocabularies and their terms can be accessed using the identifiers, preferably by both humans and machines. | Full Compliance | Full Compliance | Partial Compliance |
FVF-4: Vocabularies and their terms are registered or indexed in a searchable engine or a resource. | Full Compliance | Full Compliance | No Compliance |
FVF-5: Vocabularies and their terms are retrievable using a standardised communications protocol, preferably open, free and universally implementable protocols. and allows for authentication and authorisation, where necessary. | Full Compliance | Full Compliance | Full Compliance |
FVF-6: Vocabularies and their terms are persistent over time and are appropriately versioned. | Partial Compliance | Partial Compliance | Partial Compliance |
FVF-7: Vocabularies and their terms use a formal, accessible and broadly applicable, and preferably machine-understandable language for knowledge representation. | Full Compliance | Full Compliance | No Compliance |
FVF-8: Vocabularies and terms use qualified references to other vocabularies. | Full Compliance | Full Compliance | Partial Compliance |
FVF-9: Vocabularies and terms are described with a plurality of accurate and relevant attributes. | Full Compliance | Full Compliance | No Compliance |
FVF-10: Vocabularies are released with a standard data usage licence, preferably a machine-readable licence. | Full Compliance | Full Compliance | Full Compliance |
FVF-11: Vocabularies meet domain relevant community standards. | Full Compliance | Full Compliance | No Compliance |
FAIR Vocabulary Feature summary | |||
FVF, full compliance | 90.91\(\%\) | 81.82\(\%\) | 27.27\(\%\) |
FVF, partial compliance | 9.09\(\%\) | 9.09\(\%\) | 36.36\(\%\) |
FVF, no compliance | 0.00\(\%\) | 9.09\(\%\) | 36.36\(\%\) |