- Open Access
Trivalent influenza vaccine adverse symptoms analysis based on MedDRA terminology using VAERS data in 2011
© Du et al. 2016
- Received: 10 November 2015
- Accepted: 12 March 2016
- Published: 13 May 2016
Trivalent Influenza Virus Vaccine (FLU3) is a traditional flu vaccine to protect people against three different flu viruses, including influenza A H1N1 virus, an influenza A H3N2 virus and one B virus.
We searched Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) for US reports after FLU3 vaccination in the year of 2011. We conducted descriptive analyses on symptoms from serious reports (i.e., death, life-threatening illness, hospitalization, prolonged hospitalization, or permanent disability). We then further grouped these symptoms to the System Organ Classes (SOC) based on the MedDRA Terminology using NCBO Web Services. We fitted zero-truncated Poisson regression models to estimate the average number of symptoms per subject and compared it across different age groups and between genders. In addition, we compared the risk of occurrence for an SOC across different age groups and between genders by using logistic regression models. Finally, we constructed the pairwise correlation matrix of the SOCs by calculating Spearman’s rank correlation coefficients.
We identified 638 unique serious FLU3 reports from year 2011. There are 1410 unique symptoms from these reports. Descriptive statistics shows that the most common symptom and symptom pair are Pyrexia and Guillain-Barre syndrome – Hypoesthesia respectively. The estimated average number of symptoms per subject in the study cohort is 8.74 (95 % CI 6.76, 10.73). There are statistically significant differences in number of symptoms among four age groups and between genders. Age category and gender are significantly associated with several individual SOCs. Pairwise correlation matrix shows that “Endocrine disorders” and “Neoplasms benign, malignant and unspecified (incl cysts and polyps)” are strongly correlated.
This paper reports a novel method that combining statistical analyses with terminology grouping using VAERS data. The analyses revealed differences of reactions among different age groups and between genders and correlation on both symptoms and System Organ Class level independently. The results may lead to additional studies to uncover factors contributing to the individual differences in susceptibility to influenza infection. This method can also be applied to other vaccine types and conduct similar analysis.
- Trivalent influenza virus vaccine
Influenza (flu) is a contagious respiratory illness caused by influenza viruses, which may cause mild to severe illness including hospitalization or even death. Certain groups of people, such as the elders, young children, and those with certain health conditions, are at high risk for serious flu complications . The primary and most used method for the control of influenza and its complications are influenza vaccines. Over the years, hundreds of millions of Americans have received seasonal influenza vaccines to protect themselves against the flu viruses. Commonly, the side effects following flu vaccinations are mild, including symptoms such as soreness, redness or swelling at the injection sites, headache, muscle aches and nausea after the shot. Serious adverse reactions, however, could happen, which may cause some life-threating illness even death.
Clinical trials are generally not large enough to detect rare influenza vaccine adverse events. In 1990, Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) was created as a passive surveillance system to accept reports of adverse events following any US licensed vaccines form providers, health care workers, and the public . VAERS is co-administered by Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and the Food and Drug Administration (FDA). It is one of the largest databases containing adverse events reported in temporal association with vaccination. Since 1990, VAERS has received more than 400,000 vaccine adverse event reports, which makes it one of the most important sources to detect rare vaccine adverse events. Although VAERS cannot usually prove the causal relationships between vaccines and adverse events, it could be used to detect signals to be tested with more rigorous methods .
For years, trivalent Influenza Virus Vaccine (FLU3) is the traditional flu vaccine to protect people against three different flu viruses, including an influenza A H1N1 virus, an influenza A H3N2 virus and one B virus . Among all the VAERS reports, FLU3 is the most common vaccine type reported. Thus VAERS is a very important data source for studying FLU3 adverse events.
Much work has been done on the study of influenza adverse events using VAERS data [5–7]. Most of them only deal with some specific symptoms on the FLU3 vaccine adverse reports. A single vaccine and AE association, however, should not be considered as an isolated event. The associations of other vaccines with the same AE and other AEs with the same vaccine should also be taken into consideration .
Our research takes advantage of the Medical Dictionary for Regulatory Activities (MedDRA) terminology system for semantically grouping the VAERS adverse symptoms, which are already coded using MedDRA terms . The MedDRA Terminology is the international medical terminology developed under the auspices of the International Conference on Harmonization (ICH) of Technical Requirements for Registration of Pharmaceuticals for Human Use. MedDRA Terminology has a five-level structural hierarchy. They are lowest Level Term (LLT), Preferred Term (PT), High Level Term (HLT), High Level Group Term (HLGT), and System Organ Class (SOC). VAERSSYMPTOMS contains symptoms terms that are in the level of LLT . VAERS used symptom terms from PT, which always have its own identical term as LLT. The full MedDRA has 72,637 LLT symptoms and VAERS uses 9593 of them (13 %) . System organ class (SOC) is the highest level of the hierarchy that provides the broadest concept for data retrieval, which comprises grouping by etiology, manifestation site and purpose. MedDRA has 26 different types of SOCs and each LLT is at least linked to one SOC .
As the number of unique symptoms is relatively large in VAERS, we consider them in the SOCs to facilitate further statistical analyses. We leveraged The National Center for Biomedical Ontology (NCBO) web service to automatically map LLTs to their corresponding SOCs. The NCBO offers a range of Web services that would allow users to access various biomedical terminologies and ontologies and to identify terms from controlled terminologies and ontologies that can describe and index the contents of online data sets (data annotation) . All the MedDRA terminology system is stored in JSON format on the NCBO web services and each term is a JSON node. We used NCBO web services to search the hierarchical information of the symptom terms in the VAERS reports and assigned each symptom term one primary SOC. After grouping the symptoms to SOCs, we conducted multiple statistical analyses on the SOC level.
We searched the VAERS for US reports after FLU3 vaccination in year 2011 and extracted serious reports (i.e., death, life-threatening illness, hospitalization, pro-longed hospitalization, or permanent disability). VAERS raw data of each year contains three Comma-separated-value (CSV) files: VAERSDATA.CSV, VAERSVAX.CSV and VAERSSYMPTOMS.CSV. VAERSDATA is about the patients’ demographic information, lab test, symptom text and outcomes. VAERSVAX is about vaccine types. VAERSSYMPTOMS is about symptoms that are equivalent to the PT TERM from the MedDRA codebook. These three tables are linked by using VAERS_ID. For each report, the VAERS also provides annotations for post-vaccination symptoms in MedDRA terms. To facilitate further statistical analyses, we further grouped these symptoms based on the MedDRA SOC using the NCBO Web Services .
We calculated descriptive statistics including the number of reports, symptoms, and unique symptoms in the selected reports. We also calculated the frequency of each symptom and co-occurrence of symptom pairs.
We grouped the reports in five age groups based on cut points (0.5, 17, 49, 64) suggested by CDC . The frequency of observations in age category (0 to 0.5) is relatively small (n = 14) compared to other age categories. In order to be consistent with our previous analysis, we excluded those subjects in our data analysis, which lead to 1663 subjects .
Grouping symptoms using MedDRA terminology
SOC is the highest level of the MedDRA terms, which comprises grouping by etiology, manifestation site or purpose. Each LLT is linked to only one PT and each PT is linked to at least one SOC. This indicates that each LLT could be grouped to more than one SOC. To avoid double counting, we will need to identify the primary SOC for each term . The rules to assign SOC to the symptoms, however, are complicated, which needs expert reviews that could be time consuming and expensive.
International Agreed Orders of SOCs
Infections and infestations
Neoplasms benign, malignant and unspecified (incl cysts and polyps)
Blood and lymphatic system disorders
Immune system disorders
Metabolism and nutrition disorders
Nervous system disorders
Ear and labyrinth disorders
Respiratory, thoracic and mediastinal disorders
Skin and subcutaneous tissue disorders
Musculoskeletal and connective tissue disorders
Renal and urinary disorders
Pregnancy, puerperium and perinatal conditions
Reproductive system and breast disorders
Congenital, familial and genetic disorders
General disorders and administration site conditions
Injury, poisoning and procedural complications
Surgical and medical procedures
Sample data set we prepared for further analysis (partial, data of year 2011)
After grouping the symptoms into 26 SOCs, we explored the grouped data with regression models and correlation analysis. Specifically, we estimated the average number of symptoms per subject given stratified age groups and gender. For individual SOC, we fitted logistic regression to evaluate the association of occurrence of an SOC with age and gender. A rank-based correlation matrix is also estimated to investigate the correlation among SOCs.
Zero-truncated Poisson regression
As each subject has at least one SOC to be reported (i.e. the number of SOCs > 0), we fitted a zero-truncated Poisson regression model (a modified model of Poisson regression by excluding the probability mass at 0) to conduct data analysis . Firstly, we fitted a model with intercept only to estimate the average number of symptoms for all subjects. After that, we included covariates of age category and gender in the model to estimate and compare the number of symptoms in different age and gender strata.
To explore the association of the occurrence of individual SOC with age and gender, we conducted a logistic regression with covariates of age group and gender . The original count number of SOC is dichotomized into binary outcomes (1: SOC ≥ 1, 0: SOC = 0).
Spearman rank correlation coefficient
As the number of SOCs is highly right skewed and non-normally distributed, we use a nonparametric correlation coefficient to measure the correlation structure among SOCs. This rank based correlation coefficient is known as Spearman’s ρ . We constructed a correlation matrix of SOCs to present the pairwise correlation coefficients between SOCs.
Analysis using zero-truncated Poisson model with intercept only indicated that the estimated average number of symptoms per subject in the study cohort is 8.74 (95 % CI: 6.76, 10.73). The results from fitting zero-truncated Poisson regression with covariates age groups and gender suggest that there are statistically significant differences in the numbers of symptoms among four age groups and between different genders. The average number of symptoms per year for a female patient with age between 0.5 years and 17 years is estimated as 7.76 (95 % CI: 5.76–9.76). We use this group as the reference age group. The youngest age group (0.5–17 years) has the smallest number of symptoms per year, followed by age group 4 (>64 years), age group 2 (17–49) and finally age group 3 (49–64 years). The average number of symptoms for subjects of 17–49 years old is 1.13 times of the average number of symptoms for subjects of 0.5–17 years old with the same gender. This is consistent with previous reports about different immune responses after vaccination for different age groups. For example, there is high-dose influenza vaccine available for elders (>65) because ageing decreases the body's ability of immune response after vaccination . In addition, the males have 3.2 % lower number of symptoms. This is also consistent with previous studies that female experience more adverse reactions to influenza vaccine . We plotted the estimated residuals versus fitted values of zero-truncated Poisson regression mode. We found that the residuals are generally small and scattered around zero for most of the data points with only a few extreme values. This suggests that the zero-truncated Poisson regression model may fit the data well.
Analysis on individual SOCs also revealed some interesting results. Overall, there are 15 SOCs that show significant association with the age groups or between genders. The males have fewer responses for most SOCs except SOC1 (infections and infestations, 48.1 % more). Males are 0.369, 0.552 and 0.535 times less likely to have SOC 9 (Eye disorders), SOC 11 (Cardiac disorders) and SOC 12 (Vascular disorders) than females respectively. For SOC 14 (Gastroin-testinal disorders) and SOC 1 (Infections and infestations), female has significant higher possibilities than male. For SOC 1 (Infections and infestations), SOC 9 (Eye disorders), SOC 12 (Vascular disorders), and SOC 17 (Musculoskeletal and connective tissue disorders), people who are older than 17 show significant higher possibilities to get those adverse symptoms. Age group 3 (49–64) shows significant higher chance of experiencing symptoms relevant to infections and infestations, immune system disorders, eye disorders, vascular disorders, musculoskeletal and connective tissue disorders, surgical and medical procedures, and social circumstances compared to age group 1 (0.5–17) with the same gender. To evaluate the overall goodness of fit of the logistic regression model for each SOC, we conducted Hosmer-Lemeshow test  and calculated the corresponding p-values. Most of the p-values for all 26 tests are much smaller than 0.05, which suggests that the logistic regression model fits the data well.
This paper reports a novel method that combining statistical analyses with terminology grouping using VAERS data to study Trivalent Influenza Vaccine. Our preliminary statistical analyses reveal differences of reactions among different age groups and between genders. To our best knowledge, there are very few studies about the adverse events analysis on MedDRA SOC level. Most of our findings on the relationship between adverse events with individual difference have not been reported by other studies. The results may lead to additional studies to uncover factors contributing to the individual differences in adverse reactions to influenza vaccination.
For the limitations of this paper, due to the multiple inheritance nature of MedDRA, many symptom terms can be mapped to more than one SOCs. The order list we used to assign the primary SOC may be subjective. Ontology of Adverse Events (OAE) could provide a better hierarchy than MedDRA. The current version of OAE, however, does not include all the symptoms in the VAERS (coded in MedDRA) yet. We will consider using OAE to map the symptom terms as the OAE grows.
There are a few future directions we would like to pursue: (1) we will extend and apply the methodology to more VAERS reports over different years; and (2) this method can also be applied to other vaccine types and conduct similar analysis.
This research is partially supported by the National Library Of Medicine of the National Institutes of Health under Award Number R01LM011829. The authors also gratefully acknowledge the support from the UTHealth Innovation for Cancer Prevention Research Training Program Pre-doctoral Fellowship (Cancer Prevention and Research Institute of Texas grant # RP140103).
Open AccessThis article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Seasonal Influenza: Flu Basics http://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/disease/index.htm.
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) & Food and Drug Administration (FDA) (2015). VAERS USER GUIDE. https://vaers.hhs.gov/data/READMEJanuary2015.pdf.
- Vellozzi C, Burwen DR, Dobardzic A, Ball R, Walton K, Haber P. Safety of trivalent inactivated influenza vaccines in adults: background for pandemic influenza vaccine safety monitoring. Vaccine. 2009;27:2114–20.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) (2014a). Seasonal Influenza Vaccine Safety: A Summary for Clinicians. http://www.cdc.gov/flu/professionals/vaccination/vaccine_safety.htm.
- Haber P, Moro PL, McNeil MM, Lewis P, Woo EJ, Hughes H, Shimabukuro, TT. Post-licensure surveillance of trivalent live attenuated influenza vaccine in adults, United States, Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS), July 2005-June 2013. Vaccine. 2014;32:6499–504.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Moro PL, Broder K, Zheteyeva Y, Walton K, Rohan P, Sutherland A, Guh A, Haber P, Destefano F, Vellozzi C. Adverse events in pregnant women following administration of trivalent inactivated influenza vaccine and live attenuated influenza vaccine in the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2011;204:146.e1–7.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Moro PL, Harrington T, Shimabukuro T, Cano M, Museru OI, Menschik D, Broder K. Adverse events after Fluzone Intradermal vaccine reported to the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS), 2011–2013. Vaccine. 2013;31:4984–7.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Harpaz R, Perez H, Chase HS, Rabadan R, Hripcsak G, Friedman C. Biclustering of adverse drug events in the FDA’s spontaneous reporting system. Clin Pharmacol Ther. 2011;89:243–50.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- The International Council for Harmonisation of Technical Requirements for Pharmaceuticals for Human Use (ICH). Introductory Guide http://www.meddra.org/sites/default/files/guidance/file/intguide_14_0_english.pdf.
- National Vaccine Information Center (NAVI) (2015). MedDRA Browser. http://www.medalerts.org/vaersdb/meddra/.
- National Center for Biomedical Ontology (NCBO) (2012). NCBO Web Services and the Development of Semantic Applications. http://www.bioontology.org/wiki/index.php/NCBO_Web_Services_and_the_Development_of_Semantic_Applications.
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) (2012). Estimates from the Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System (BRFSS), National Immunization Survey (NIS), and the National 2009 H1N1 Flu Survey (NHFS). http://www.cdc.gov/flu/fluvaxview/trends/age-groups.htm.
- Tao C, Du J, Cai Y, Chen Y. Trivalent Influenza Vaccine Adverse Event Analysis Based On MedDRA System Organ Classes Using VAERS Data, 15th World Congress on Health and Biomedical Informatics (MEDINFO 2015), São Paulo, 2015.Google Scholar
- Clifford CA. Estimating parameters in a conditional Poisson distribution. Biometrics. 1960;16:203–11.MathSciNetView ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Hosmer DW, Lemeshow S. Applied Logistic Regression. 2nd ed. 2005.MATHGoogle Scholar
- Spearman C. The proof and measurement of association between two things. Am J Psychol. 1904;15:72–101.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Chit A, Roiz J, Briquet B, Greenberg DP. Expected cost effectiveness of high-dose trivalent influenza vaccine in US seniors. Vaccine. 2015;33(5):734–41.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Beyer WEP, Palache AM, Kerstens R, Masurel N. Gender differences in local and systemic reactions to inactivated influenza vaccine, established by a meta-analysis of fourteen independent studies. Eur J Clin Microbiol Infect Dis. 1996;15:65–70.View ArticleGoogle Scholar
- Evans JD. Straightforward Statistics for the Behavioral Sciences. Pacific Grove: Brooks/Cole; 1996.Google Scholar